Court Imposes $11 Million Penalty on Advice Firm for Breaching Remuneration Rules

4

DOD Bookkeeping, now in liquidation, had previously incentivized three financial advisers by paying them a total of $130,250 in bonuses. These advisers were found to have improperly encouraged clients to roll over their superannuation into self-managed superannuation funds (SMSFs) and subsequently purchase properties through Equiti Property, a related entity. Each bonus payment ranged from $750 to $1500, with advisers receiving multiple bonuses each year.

Equiti Financial Services offered a suite of services, including financial advice, SMSF establishment and administration, real estate recommendations through Equiti Property, and mortgage broking via Equiti Finance. However, its Australian financial services licence was revoked by ASIC in November 2024, following a payment from the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort.

During the court proceedings, testimonies from 12 clients surfaced, highlighting the firm's failure to tailor financial advice to personal circumstances. Evidence showed that two advisers earned almost $240,000 annually, with nearly 40 percent of their income stemming from bonuses—heightening concerns of conflicted advice.

The court's judgment emphasized the detrimental influence the bonus payments had on the advisers' recommendations, violating the conflicted remuneration laws introduced in 2013 under the Future of Financial Advice reforms. These laws aim to prevent financial advisers from receiving incentives that could bias their advice or product recommendations.

This ruling underscores the rigorous standards expected in Australia's SMSF sector and highlights the legal responsibilities of financial advisers to act in clients' best interests. ASIC's commitment to enforcing these standards seeks to uphold the integrity of financial advice and protect consumers from biased product promotions.

As part of its ongoing efforts to enhance accountability within the financial sector, ASIC plans to ramp up scrutiny of SMSF advice. This includes conducting comprehensive reviews, with the findings due in late 2025. The sector faces mounting pressure to raise operational standards and restrict access to SMSFs to suitable candidates, particularly as more claims may implicate the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort.

ASIC Deputy Chair Sarah Court highlighted the significance of the penalty, emphasizing the need for financial service licensees to prioritize client interests above all. This judgment serves as a stern warning to firms that exploit contractual loopholes for financial gain at consumers' expense.

Published:Friday, 2nd May 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Finance News

Clear

Calls Intensify for Swift Financial Advice Reforms in Australia 06 May 2025: Paige Estritori Amid pressing concerns from industry associations, the call for rapid finalization of financial advice reforms in Australia has been amplified. The lack of direction from the Labour government regarding the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort (CSLR) is causing uncertainty in the sector, potentially stalling essential reform work. The impending retirement of Stephen Jones has only added to the speculation surrounding the future of these reforms. - read more

Unlocking Income Opportunities Through Commercial Real Estate Debt 06 May 2025: Paige Estritori Investors are increasingly discovering income prospects in commercial real estate (CRE) without owning property directly. CRE debt investments offer a popular method to generate returns by lending to those requiring capital for commercial property ventures. The investors' gains are derived from borrowing costs, encompassing interest and fees, once fund expenses are deducted. - read more

Navigating the Challenges of Bond Income Distributions 05 May 2025: Paige Estritori As global bond yields experience a resurgence, many income-seeking investors face diminishing returns from cash distributions. According to a recent analysis by investment researcher Zenith, a noticeable discrepancy has emerged between the average yields of bond fund portfolios and their actual income distributions. - read more

Westpac Records Slight Profit Drop Amid Geopolitical Risk Concerns 05 May 2025: Paige Estritori In a cautious signal to the market, Westpac has recorded a marginal decline in its half-year profit, posting a $3.45 billion result, down by one per cent compared to previous figures. This financial outcome marks the first under the direction of their new CEO, Anthony Miller, who commenced his role in December last year. Westpac has flagged geopolitical unpredictability as a significant ongoing risk, reflecting a challenging environment for the financial sector. - read more

US Federal Reserve Rate Decision Grips Australian Investors 04 May 2025: Paige Estritori The upcoming interest rate decision by the US Federal Reserve is creating significant anticipation among Australian investors. As the announcement is set for Thursday, the market is particularly keen on understanding the future direction beyond the expected maintenance of the current cash rate, which Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has previously indicated for May. - read more

Court Imposes $11 Million Penalty on Advice Firm for Breaching Remuneration Rules 02 May 2025: Paige Estritori The Federal Court has imposed a substantial $11 million penalty on a financial advice firm after discovering the firm breached conflicted remuneration regulations. The case revealed that DOD Bookkeeping, formerly Equiti Financial Services, engaged in practices that involved providing standardized advice that improperly favored in-house property investments. - read more